I would advise a mineral make-up in powder form in your situation. All liquid formulas are going to expire on you (and separate out or go all weird eventually even if you don't mind or notice that they expired three years ago). As a bonus, it is very easy to find ethical brands in this space and smaller indie companies. Many sell on Etsy or you can check your local hippie grocers. Even Sephora has some options that meet your criteria. (I would have recommended my favourites but both closed down after over a decade or two acouple years ago. I am going to be sad when I finally need to buy my eyebrow powder though.)