Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Educational-Walk8098 t1_jdf8ctj wrote

We obtain 7/7/5 with confidence score 5/4/4. Our rebuttal addresses the questions and comments of each reviewer but we could not make it on time for an additional experiment that one of the reviewer may find interesting. Our rebuttal was well-written but there are some points we wish that we could express in another way. I'm now extremely worried if it could negatively affect the final recommendations of the reviewers. None of the reviewers respond to my rebuttal yet...

2

underPanther t1_jdgli5w wrote

The 7s would not give these scores already unless they were prepared to argue for the acceptance of your paper in its current state.

Extra experiments are always nice, but I would be proud of yourself for the hard work that you have done already instead of the one experiment that you can't do.

2

Educational-Walk8098 t1_jdh0ah0 wrote

Yeah you're probably right. Thanks a lot for your kind advice! My reviewers' comments are insightful and very helpful to improve our manuscript so I just want to respond to their feedback in the best way that I can.

1