Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

[deleted] t1_jdt9g2f wrote

A reviewer suddenly lowered the score and wrote a concern just a few hours before the end of the discussion period. Since the reviewer revised the original official review, I didn’t get notified.

The reason for lowering the score is that we did not apply to other algorithms and other datasets. If so, I wonder why the reviewer didn’t talk about it earlier and give us a chance to respond during the rebuttal or discussion period.

3

Anonymous_Penguin1 t1_jdty4ed wrote

It seems that you can still make an official comment now on OpenReview :) But not pretty sure if that would violate some rule.

2