I'm going posit that the reason you so many more responses from PA than NY is probably…the luck of the draw.

It sounds like you don't have so much of a reason to pass up these offers. You won't be too far from “home.” Take an offer and see if you like it here.

It's pretty easy to get form Allentown/Bethlehem to NYC. From Lancaster, Harrisburg or York, it's farther, but the train makes it easy.

If it's not a fit, in a year or two, circulate your resume again. This time, you'll have experience, and it will be easier to find a job where you like.