Submitted by hufsa7 t3_zgm8q4 in askscience
forte2718 t1_izjbahw wrote
Reply to comment by dukesdj in Can you predictably manipulate a magnetic gas? by hufsa7
> ... We can consider two regimes which are categorized by the magnetic Reynolds number (Rm). ... In the simple case with low Rm then the field strongly influences the flow but the flow does not strongly influence the field. The high Rm case is more difficult as the field and flow are strongly coupled and Alfvens frozen flux theorem is applicable (which essentially says that the fluid flow is frozen to the magnetic field and vice versa).
Huh ... I'm curious, is there any intermediate regime, however small or poorly-understood it might be, where there is some substantial back-reaction of the flow onto the field but not enough to freeze the fluid flow to the magnetic field ... or is there essentially a hard phase transition between the two behaviors?
Cheers!
dukesdj t1_izjhh15 wrote
It varies continuously. We typically define these regimes in the asymptotic limit of infinite or infinitely small. The frozen flux theorem is strictly applicable for the case of infinite conductivity (infinite Rm) which is non-physical but a very good approximation for most stellar applications.
forte2718 t1_izjk26h wrote
Neat, thank you!
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments