Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

lellololes t1_jdh6w03 wrote

Reply to comment by Audrin in Comparison of Star Trek Series by IMBD Ratings [OC] by insaneplane

Season 3 of Picard would change your mind.

I think episode 6 leaned in too much on nostalgia, but the season started OK and just keeps getting better and better.

I felt like Picard got off to an interesting start at the beginning but completely fumbled the rest, and season 2 was not good, though it fleshed out some of his history, which may be of some interest - but the way they did it was weird.

But now I feel like Picard isn't some old dude wandering in to trouble. He feels like elder Picard should. Even Raffi is bearable now, if not one of the better characters.

1

Audrin t1_jdhdet7 wrote

I'm watching it. It's still not good. Everyone saying it's suddenly great has Stockholm syndrome.

​

It's much much better than Picard season 1 & 2, 10x better, but that's like going from a 0.1/10 to a 1/10.

​

There are TNG episodes that are 10/10 and the best Picard episode maybe reaches a 3. MAYBE.

0

lellololes t1_jdhkxi4 wrote

You can like the show or not, that's fine.

But I can say with confidence that your opinion that Shades or Gray is better than any episode of Picard is not something that many people would share.

I didn't care for season 1 and 2, but they had their moments too - and they were all better than the absolute worst of TNG. When your benchmark on a 1-10 scale is 0.1-1, you're being ridiculously hyperbolic.

I sentence you to repeated viewings of Shades of Gray, Sub Rosa, and Code of Honor!

0