Submitted by IslandChillin t3_z3zl37 in history
Comments
ConsitutionalHistory t1_ixohysm wrote
Fascinating...so many truly brilliant people in the world.
lalalachie t1_ixojz9k wrote
Incredible! Is there a copy of the actual transcription anywhere? Would love to know what the letter said verbatim.
[deleted] t1_ixoocey wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixoot5g wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixor0du wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixouawq wrote
[removed]
Rear-gunner t1_ixourma wrote
I would love to see that too.
[deleted] t1_ixov272 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixow1ln wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixownh2 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixoxetn wrote
[removed]
RoutinePost7443 t1_ixoy23w wrote
It's a rather unsatisfying write-up! Long on pats in the back and short on actual information. Interesting nevertheless.
[deleted] t1_ixp0kpo wrote
[removed]
phasefournow t1_ixp0okp wrote
I know historians say most of the archived and untranslated or un-decoded documents sitting in museum and university storage rooms are dull invoices, agricultural and trade documents but no doubt there are also many gems such as this, just waiting to be revealed someday by a tenacious researcher willing to do the work needed to uncover the contents.
[deleted] t1_ixp1k1j wrote
[removed]
BrokenEye3 t1_ixp1l6w wrote
Or instructions on how to use the code
[deleted] t1_ixp1pqa wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixp1tg6 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixp1vzb wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixp29qo wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixp2wkt wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixp8i08 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixp8wqt wrote
[deleted] t1_ixpb3v6 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpbth4 wrote
[removed]
Permanent_Confusion t1_ixpdgg3 wrote
I think that's Pam Beesly checking out the back of the document..
[deleted] t1_ixpdpdo wrote
[removed]
mastovacek t1_ixpexzo wrote
> dull invoices, agricultural and trade documents
Those I would personally like even more! They would allow for a better picture of the economic reality of the time and serve to inform on the impacts of various events.
Snoo_73835 t1_ixpf3gr wrote
So exciting! I can’t wait until they do a book about it!!
Fyodor_Dostoyevskeet t1_ixphkoj wrote
Seems the only info released so far is this press release from Agence France-Presse.
Drevil335 t1_ixpioal wrote
That is really, really cool. It's honestly quite fascinating how we're somehow still uncovering new material about a man who's been dead for nearly 500 years. I wonder how many other ciphered letters, both for Charles V and other past rulers as well, are still sitting around, waiting to be deciphered.
[deleted] t1_ixpjpwb wrote
[deleted]
[deleted] t1_ixpk9ae wrote
[removed]
Aware-Reveal7950 t1_ixpmqoj wrote
Well, what’s it say then?
[deleted] t1_ixpnmqh wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpop0q wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixppqe5 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpqbld wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixprdm2 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixprokp wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpryk2 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpsksv wrote
[removed]
ComCypher t1_ixpt5a1 wrote
I'm most curious to know how one cracks a word-based substitution without knowing the key.
[deleted] t1_ixpt90t wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixptt6o wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpuuni wrote
[removed]
rockdog85 t1_ixpuunu wrote
​
One of the senders scribbled part of the code in the margins, which helped to find more similarities
[deleted] t1_ixpvbpa wrote
[removed]
Red_Khalmer t1_ixpw0h4 wrote
The article says what OP wrote above, didn't you just read it?
[deleted] t1_ixpwjv6 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpwz1m wrote
[removed]
Owl_lamington t1_ixpxx2c wrote
So what does it say?
StingerAE t1_ixpy1hn wrote
I think they meant the letter not the article!
StingerAE t1_ixpy5og wrote
Invoices might be untranslated but unlikely to have been in code. Maybe shorthand.
[deleted] t1_ixpy9ty wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpyx7g wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixpz0e8 wrote
[removed]
jon_stout t1_ixpz95m wrote
Something about rumors of the French whipping up an assassination plot against Charles.
Elluminated t1_ixpzfpm wrote
Lets hold a 596 year old document wiyh our bare hands
[deleted] t1_ixpzg5j wrote
[deleted]
[deleted] t1_ixq1xdv wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixq1xx8 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixq3189 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixq4d16 wrote
[removed]
ButterUtters t1_ixq72x8 wrote
I'm not sure what for, but that photo is meme material for sure.
In_shpurrs t1_ixqb4sm wrote
Yes, there are. All you need to do is watch out for the trap of being the most brilliant; much like trying to be the most beautiful: there's always someone more beautiful. Want to be the funniest? There's always someone funnier. Think you're the most brilliant? You'll hit a wall when you mest someone smarter. So it goes.
[deleted] t1_ixqbabl wrote
[removed]
Currywurst_Is_Life t1_ixqc9ba wrote
"We've been trying to contact you regarding your royal coach's extended warranty."
LJR07 t1_ixqca3l wrote
They "crack" a letter that's almost 500 years old and give us the cliff notes... brilliant.
[deleted] t1_ixqco9p wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixqcxpf wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixqe54p wrote
[deleted]
[deleted] t1_ixqe65v wrote
[removed]
SharksForArms t1_ixqeb4h wrote
"Well we cracked the code! But it's not very interesting or relevant and I am in the middle of decluttering, so... paper shredder noise
[deleted] t1_ixqec4p wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixqfekw wrote
[removed]
big_duo3674 t1_ixqgb8s wrote
You make it sound like it was a casual Saturday afternoon for them. "Nah I don't got much planned today, just whipping up a quick plot to assassinate a monarch so I should be free by 2"
[deleted] t1_ixqh228 wrote
[removed]
chaosperfect t1_ixqh323 wrote
I was under the impression that that's how it normally works.
[deleted] t1_ixqhqdn wrote
[deleted]
[deleted] t1_ixqiba0 wrote
[removed]
chaosperfect t1_ixqifsk wrote
I'm aware of that. But don't academics, historians, archeologists, scientists, astronomers, etc traditionally give everything away for free? It'd be pretty depressing if what motivated the top minds in the world to discover and release new information and breakthroughs was just money.
subito_lucres t1_ixqj7ur wrote
You are generally correct! Of course there are exceptions. I'm not sure how that all works for historians. For science, you generally release the idea and anyone can use it for research, but also patent it so that people have to pay you if they want to make money off of it.
Source: am academic scientist.
snkn179 t1_ixqjxvf wrote
Looks like we can date the letter to the early part of 1547 then, considering Francis died in March that year.
[deleted] t1_ixqkckd wrote
[removed]
chaosperfect t1_ixqktu0 wrote
That seems fair. I'm pleased.
Edit: Also, thank you for your service.
recumbent_mike t1_ixql7ye wrote
Probably don't want to risk divulging classified information.
Throwaway_7451 t1_ixqmpvb wrote
"This message still contains information vital to national security, therefore we cannot release it"
subito_lucres t1_ixqoqgs wrote
Hahaha, no one has ever thanked me for being a scientist. But I appreciate you appreciating it! Sometimes I actually feel guilty for asking for government grants because some of that money comes out of real people's pockets.
lukasx98 t1_ixqpfp4 wrote
Definitely, the state of trade and agriculture could make or break a war or an alliance for example. I could see it giving valuable context to decisions made by rulers during the time the document was written.
[deleted] t1_ixqq4v1 wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixqq6gm wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixqqu9s wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixqrb49 wrote
HeyCarpy t1_ixqrd9z wrote
I would've liked a more detailed breakdown of the phrase that broke the code as well. This article left me wanting more, and not in a good way.
therealCatnuts t1_ixqrkf3 wrote
You ever try to read Middle English from 500 years ago? It’s unreadable. Probably a big issue here.
Duff-Zilla t1_ixqsxli wrote
Turns out is says “I love big anime tiddys!”
BeerorCoffee t1_ixqtrb5 wrote
Wouldn't it have been written in Spanish?
Kubliah t1_ixqvapi wrote
"I have my wedding to prepare, my wife to murder, and Gilder to frame for it. I'm swamped."
SmilingAtTheSun t1_ixqve55 wrote
This is so true. I would tweak what you said slightly…what you need to watch out for is “trying” to be the most brilliant, beautiful, funny etc. It’s a recipe for perpetual unhappiness.
_O_G_ t1_ixqzr2f wrote
1540s would be early Modern English not Middle English, so don’t think legibility is as big an issue as you’re implying. Also this dude was the Holy Roman Emperor so it probably wasn’t even written in English
StinkMartini t1_ixr0vbp wrote
Get some rest - if you haven't got you health, you haven't got anything!
BenMottram2016 t1_ixr1hm8 wrote
Why not?
Clean hands are the safest way to handle documents like this...
The classic white gloves are well out of favour these days because they snag on page edges, leave fibres everywhere and make the wearer considerably more clumsy.
Edit: one of many
The_Original_Gronkie t1_ixr2e5q wrote
They're writing a book, probably. I don't blame them. It's a cool story.
IactaEstoAlea t1_ixr7ai2 wrote
Nonsense! They were family!
> My cousin Francis and I are in perfect accord. He wants Milan and so do I.
Charles V, HRE
JRCIII t1_ixr7ps5 wrote
Usually its based on symbol patterns in the letter. If they can decode one or two common phrases the rest kinda falls into place over time.
Things they look for are double consonants or where two symbols are paired together.
i.e if you have a letter where the words "Space and "Race" are used then in theory the "-ace" portion of both words should use the same symbols. So plug that in everywhere you see the corresponding symbols, then work fill in as many of those as possible using other repeating patterns and guess and check.
konichiwaaaaaa t1_ixr8b3o wrote
They made out one sentence. That’s often the flaw of encryption methods. It can be like Sudoku, where if you know some symbols you can find others.
ResearchWarrior t1_ixr9y01 wrote
“Another letter from Jean de Saint-Mauris, where the receiver had doodled a form of transcription code in the margin, also helped.” Soooooo… they cracked the code by reading this guy’s answer key?
[deleted] t1_ixrbzmf wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_ixrds5u wrote
[deleted]
[deleted] t1_ixrfbrt wrote
[removed]
IslandChillin OP t1_ixofot9 wrote
"Whole words are encrypted with a single symbol and the emperor replaced vowels coming after consonants with marks, she said, an inspiration probably coming from Arabic.
In another obstacle, he also used symbols that mean nothing to mislead any adversary trying to decipher the message.
The breakthrough came in June, when Pierrot managed to make out a phrase in the letter, and the team then cracked the code with the help of historian Camille Desenclos."
"It was painstaking and long work but there was really a breakthrough that happened in one day, where all of a sudden we had the right hypothesis," she said.
"Another letter from Jean de Saint-Mauris, where the receiver had doodled a form of transcription code in the margin, also helped."