Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

paulsmt t1_iyyvuto wrote

What a horrible idea. Unless it's an emergency, nobody should be blabbing on the phone inside a tin can.

96

dabestgoat t1_iyyw6pq wrote

Mental Image of the future: 50-100 people all cross talking on their devices making the cabin crew distributing those 2 cookies and one gulp of tomato juice even more painful when all you wanna do is take a raging piss and they are still 15 seats up blocking the only washroom.

79

1320Fastback t1_iyyw9y0 wrote

Hey you shut up for a minute and put your tray table up for landing!

8

canuckcowgirl t1_iyyxn4h wrote

Ugh. People will have no choice but to eavesdrop whether they want to or not.

8

sl8rfan2 t1_iyyxpb7 wrote

that's going to be really annoying. You know those people who like to put their phones on speaker and yell into it for a half hour...yeah, now imagine that on the plane sitting next to you.

FUCK THAT.

544

KindAwareness3073 t1_iyyy32x wrote

No. No. No. I do not want to listen to one side of your morononic conversation for the next three hours.

143

alexb3678 t1_iyyylyd wrote

Using the in air Wi-Fi? Usually the thing restricting calls is the whole 30,000ft and 600mph… well except for that one time.

54

OccamsSchickQuattro t1_iyyzs4g wrote

I almost never put my phone on airplane mode simply because it’s never been properly explained to me as to why it needs to exist. In a normal 6 hour flight I’ll have good enough reception to receive a text maybe two times. Just turning off airplane mode isn’t going to allow anyone to do anything they can’t already do on a plane.

I still need to use the in air Wi-Fi if I want to send a text message out or if I want to watch in air entertainment.

The point in which your device stops working even when you don’t use airplane mode is super quick. Just last week I was watching the hockey game during takeoff and it was within 1 minute of us taking off that my phone could no longer support the game.

I don’t think this really changes anything either way.

−8

2021newusername t1_iyyzxbm wrote

my iphone 12 screen wouldn’t respond to touching at all. couldn’t turn it off or put on airplane mode.
6 hours flight, then a 15 hour flight, neither plane crashed lol.

−14

Honest_Its_Bill_Nye t1_iyz0im6 wrote

I just flew home from Ireland Saturday. The difference in service on the "international" (Dublin to Boston) leg vs. the "domestic" (Boston to San Francisco) on the same airline was stark. The first 7 hour leg served lunch and dinner, plus free champagne, wine, and beer. The second 7 hour flight served half a can of diet coke and a cookie.

49

Obversa t1_iyz0pr7 wrote

Imagine this, but their screaming child is also kicking the back of your seat for most of the entire 8-hour cross-Atlantic flight on your way from the United States to Germany.

11

networksmuggler t1_iyz1avb wrote

Lol I actually got a wifi call some how while traveling. I had subscribed to the flights wifi service for the flight but surprised the shit out of me when my phone rang. I kept it short because I felt super awkward about it.

5

RenegadeSoundWAV t1_iyz1ns8 wrote

Not an electrical engineer nor an expert on this matter, but there used to be a time where cell phone bands weren't well regulated and the EM waves would interfere with communication devices. I remember this being a much bigger problem when I was in high school, where even cell phones on silent would interfere with the wireless microphones for our stage productions.

But I do know the reason they ask for all devices to be put on airplane mode or turned off - it is because it's easier to issue a blanket statement than require specific devices to be turned off.

I'm assuming the EU evaluated that the risk is nearly negligible - probably because the odds of anyone using such outdated tech is practically null.

6

Shumina-Ghost t1_iyz2o3o wrote

Man, I'll stay off my phone during the flight. How about this tho, let me KEEP MY MOTHER FUCKING SHOES AND BELT ON AT THE FUCKING AIRPORT.

−1

Capable_Nature_644 t1_iyz2p3p wrote

I know people who yap like crazy on a phone and have loud voices. God that's going to be frustrating to enjoy a quiet flight. They need to set rules and regulations on usage to keep some control over it.

20

Omegalazarus t1_iyz3f34 wrote

Asimov was right. We'll only have the bathrooms left.

7

LLCoolDave82 t1_iyz4lcl wrote

And here I thought the social contract still existed in Europe. Bad Europe, bad!

−4

Zhelthan t1_iyz5aen wrote

Oh god no please people are already annoying without the ability to make phone call

9

limabeantwothree t1_iyz5ghs wrote

Psh, maybe for you this is an issue. For me, I will make it THEIR issue. Moaning sounds, coughs, trying to butt into the conversation, etc. I've been using these tactics to get people to stfu and end the call for years, only the most unruly of Phoenix residents were impervious to them!

124

008Zulu t1_iyz5gvs wrote

Because there too many mobile phones, all built to very different standards, that it would be impossible to test them all against every type and configuration of electronics suite in every model of plane. In all likelihood they are safe, but no one wants to take the risk. So we have airplane mode.

The article specifies that 5G is the band approved in the planes, likely because European electronics standards (in planes) are higher than American, so knowing the frequencies it would be easier to have that one band instead of the 2G/3G/4G range.

3

vellyr t1_iyz70ur wrote

I'll admit I've never tried to do a conference call on a flight. Do they specifically block those services? Because you should be able to do a Teams call or something on any device with an internet connection.

6

_Levitated_Shield_ t1_iyz8jy8 wrote

Yeah, that'll surely reduce annoyances, especially if you're aboard a long flight. Brilliant idea...

5

Deyln t1_iyza90e wrote

The reason why there were banned was because planes had a frequency vulnerability. So instead of fixing it.... They banned it and left the vulnerability open for hacking.

(And another couple big what the fucks on regards to security )

14

fkmeamaraight t1_iyzava3 wrote

This is going to be hell will all these cum buckets who have phones on speaker mode for phone calls, music and videos. It's already insanely annoying on the metros and trams. Btw, when did it become acceptable to be so fucking selfish ?

5

---------_----_---_ t1_iyzc6fq wrote

This is a horrible mistake.

Being stuck for hours next to someone yapping into a phone is a form of torture.

5

lensupthere t1_iyzchvf wrote

Kids are kids, it doesn't matter which section they sit in.

I fly first class all the time for work - I also raised two kids. I don't mind kids at all, but some people can be really annoying with their reactions to them. These people are not really first class people.

−5

chantillylace9 t1_iyzlyra wrote

OK, is it just me that I have noticed that nowadays the iPhone is super difficult to hear unless you have it on speaker?

If I just have it up towards my ear like a normal person would, I cannot hear anything!! This started maybe about five years ago, so speaker is the only thing that I can actually hear.

8

toodog t1_iyzokae wrote

I’m Spending a six hour flight in the toilet also the seat is bigger

2

GreenGod42069 t1_iyzpvey wrote

Lol. So those idiots who don't even bother to turn phones into airplane mode are being proven right??? Man, I used to hate those asshats who ignored repeated requests to turn phones into airplane mode. Oh well. How the turntables, I guess.

−1

orus t1_iyzr794 wrote

No one really checks if someone’s phone is in airplane mode. If it were that critical a vulnerability, they would be more serious about it or there would have been hacks already.

45

[deleted] t1_iyzsibi wrote

From the pilot side of it, we can tell when someone’s phone isn’t in airplane mode. It’s not every time but it happens frequently that when we get close to the ground we can hear our nav radios get scratchy.

4

CriticalMembership31 t1_iyzsl4p wrote

Idk if it has to do with domestic vs international, but after living overseas for a year and traveling from Bahrain to Germany and Ireland I have a whole new hatred for American domestic travel and American based air lines. I remember buying my ticket to Germany and it being around 500 bucks….then trying to buy a plane ticket from DC to Texas for 600-700 bucks. The prices alone threw me way off.

20

WirelessBCupSupport t1_iyzw4ue wrote

How about screening people that are on medication AND drinks prior to boarding....

−1

CPargermer t1_iyzy7n4 wrote

This is the thing for me. People that don't speak the language, people that forget, people that don't know how, people that resist authority... There are so many chances for them to not put their phone into airplane mode, yet you never hear of any problems.

16

Wes_WM t1_iyzzdjo wrote

I have joined teams calls, multiple times. I make it a point to only listen and not speak to be respectful to those around me, but it does work

1

OccamsSchickQuattro t1_iz01xwp wrote

Hey man if it annoys the people flying the big metal tubes that’s enough reason for me. I fly a lot and I’ve noticed they’ve even stopped calling it out so I figured it was just an antiquated idea.

2

SuperSpy- t1_iz03edl wrote

I hope they don't actually get rid of the airplane mode switch on smartphones. It's such a convenient way to shut off the radios when they are misbehaving and you need to, for instance, force the phone to re-connect to the cellular network when it's misbehaving.

8

personalhale t1_iz03pbk wrote

What flights have y'all been on where this has not already been a thing? I haven't used airplane mode in years and usually use inflight Wifi. I've seen many many people making calls in the air. Do y'all not travel with headphones or earplugs?

3

estherstein t1_iz08xmt wrote

Ugh someone on one of my Thanksgiving flights literally did this with a WhatsApp call right behind me the whole time. I asked him to shut up multiple times but he didn't and it's not like I could have taken him in a fight...

2

BigDisk t1_iz0a8eu wrote

It would also be more effective to just come out and say something to the lines of "Please put your phones in airplane mode, otherwise the constant searching for a signal is gonna kill your battery."

7

Pinuzzo t1_iz0cwuf wrote

These comments are weird. Your phones don't get signal at cruising altitude anyway, only at takeoff and landing when you are close enough to the towers.

2

APigNamedLucy t1_iz0d6un wrote

How does that work? I don't get signal on planes even when I don't have my phone in airplane mode. In my limited understanding, you're generally too high above the clouds to get the signals that are reflecting off clouds and from radio towers.

1

Relevant_Quantity_49 t1_iz0fmxe wrote

And I use an iPhone and don't have that problem. The only iPhone user I know who does has documented hearing loss. Personal experiences aren't exactly scientific studies or conclusive in any way. It's a possibility. It's not a certainty. Only OP can decide what to do with it.

5

IdleRocket t1_iz0iiav wrote

I'm calling bullshit that you have flown a single flight where all 150+ passengers have turned airplane mode on. I'm guessing your scratchy radios are something else.

0

International_Bat_87 t1_iz0k0bb wrote

Possibly I remember getting my iPhone X and after three month the sound was absolutely atrocious because I’ve never called only texted since then. I bought an Apple Watch because of it then I never had a problem after I think I was just given a faulty phone. Newest MacBook I have from this year sound = flawless

2

thegreatRMH t1_iz0klk4 wrote

Will airlines actually allow you to carry on a conversation? All the US airlines have high speed internet on domestic flights now but still ban calling apps because it's disturbing to other passengers.

1

ikarikh t1_iz0osaa wrote

It'll be just like bus' then. It's absolutely annoying when you're on the bus and people are blasting music through their speaker phones and having loud ass phone conversations.

People have NO consideration for others and will look at YOU as being the asshole if you even POLITELY ask them to be quiet.

Is it really that difficult to sit still and be quiet during your trip? Or if you wanna listen to music or watch a video, to use friggin headphones (and not have the volume so loud it's still blaring out of the headphones)?

I mean obviously of course it is, because these fuckers do it every day with zero fucks given at who they're annoying :P

1

MaliciousWolf t1_iz0qbbg wrote

A lot of phones can make calls over VOIP, iPhones in particular. This is done via in-cabin wifi, which is available in air thanks to satellite receivers/transmitters installed on the plane. People have making calls for years now thanks to this service while in-flight, even though some airlines prohibit this.

2

Obi_Uno t1_iz143aw wrote

My understanding is this would allow 5G connectivity via picocells installed in the airplane itself.

I’m not clear on the advantage vs WiFi, since the backhaul would still be via satellite (which is the rate limiter).

10

Obi_Uno t1_iz14zdo wrote

That’s what the entire proposal is about: it allows airlines to install 5G picocells in the aircraft.

Previously, this spectrum was banned in flight, so this was not a possibility.

2

APigNamedLucy t1_iz1c8bt wrote

Okay, I knew there was an option to make wifi calls, but I'd never tried it on a plane. Is it usually automatic, or do you have to do something to activate it? I thought it was just the regular, make a call stuff that you do anywhere.

1

MaliciousWolf t1_iz1e5xi wrote

iPhone is usually automatic when connected to wifi, however I believe you need to utilize the call option via the FaceTime app, not the phone app to initiate a VOIP call when out of service but connected to wifi and basically bypass the need of communicating with cell towers to relay the call as at that point it uses your contact and your apple IDs to make the call over VOIP. For android, there are third party apps you can install that allow you to make VOIP call, anything such as Skype to even Microsoft Teams would work. Of course these require the appropriate accounts and your contact to have an account and utilize these same apps as well.

There are devices that could be installed on the plane that emit the appropriate cell tower frequencies and allow phones to connect to them and then broadcast their data back over standard IP as well, though I haven’t encountered this on a plane yet but I know such options are already in use by some consumers and businesses and could see this be implemented on a plane to make both calls and data hassle free for customers in the future.

2

Venkman_P t1_iz1eh2j wrote

Tell me you never read the articles, reddit, without telling me.

1

40ozkiller t1_iz1k8a1 wrote

Never, this is all just fake outrage for something that hasn’t even happened yet.

Id rather have someone making a call than a baby crying. Noise cancelling headphones also exist if you cant survive a few hours of background noise.

4

BloopityBlue t1_iz1v2cn wrote

i barely have service if I go behind the wrong tree, I can't even begin to imagine trying to keep a call going that high up.

1

KindAwareness3073 t1_iz1ylqi wrote

Do you go out in public? Why do you think civilized people don't have protracted phone conversations in bar, restaurants, museums? Why do people on buses and subways yammering on their phones get confronted? If you think hard about it I bet you'll see there's a fundamental difference.

2

EmperorArthur t1_iz2yapr wrote

Huh. Yeah, I don't see a problem with that. A picocell has about the same power as a WiFi Hotspot. Even better, they undergo significantly more testing and regulatory evaluation.

Any avionics which are affected by either of those are absolutely defective.

Random fun fact, the good Pilot headsets have bluetooth built in. Netflix downloads was a game changer for many pilots.

3

EmperorArthur t1_iz2ymj5 wrote

Another person mentioned a 5G picocell. They're things you can buy when you have poor cell service, but good internet.

Mind you, most new phones already have WiFi calling, so nothing really is changing for many people.

1

SuperSpy- t1_iz36yex wrote

Yeah, especially on iOS, since in the last few years they changed it so that 'turning off cellular' just disables the use of the data connection instead of actually disconnecting from the tower and shutting off the radio.

2

sololander t1_iz5gu73 wrote

I wonder if the network provider still makes the final call? Because right now almost all UAE, Saudi and Qatar based airlines offer cell service but it’s your provider who charges your extra inflight roaming. So even if it’s 5g but if I get charged a bomb compared to paying 5 euros for data and network I hardly see a difference..

1

sololander t1_iz5hdme wrote

Phones can get signal if your provider has options or tie ups with the in flight network. Any flight of emirates, Etihad or saudia if you have and Middle Easters sim or Asian one it shows 4g network on normal phone. Coz well it’s always been a thing. Charges are outrageous for roaming though.

1