Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

[deleted] t1_j5wfjnl wrote

[deleted]

−8

[deleted] t1_j5wkfoc wrote

[deleted]

52

TheCatapult t1_j5x0egh wrote

This is an incredibly naive take. These workers are trafficked in by Chinese criminal organizations, working on Chinese owned farms, and being exploited by Chinese gangs. There are no other cultures or races directly involved except Chinese.

The level of sophistication of the criminal activities is far beyond what other criminal organizations are doing in the US.

You can ignore the truth, or realize that this is what we’re dealing with in the US. Just ask the company president Xianmin Guan

−18

breadexpert69 t1_j5wk0gp wrote

Why would you imply he was illegal right away?

He could have had a work visa and renewed it.

Just cuz you are not a citizen living here does not mean you are illegal.

23

LimitedSwimmer t1_j5whonu wrote

What makes you think that? Not saying you are wrong but nothing in your quoted text could lead to that conclusion.

13

alphabeticdisorder t1_j5wjlwj wrote

I think the headline sort of implies it. If he was here 10 years it seems a little weird to describe him as an immigrant unless its relevant. He'd be just like any other farm worker committing mass murder.

3

breadexpert69 t1_j5wk854 wrote

Yes but articles love to use the word “immigrant” because it makes readers tingle.

17

TriFolk t1_j5wjyo2 wrote

The way it’s written it says he’s not a resident or citizen and rather a Chinese citizen however nothing is stated that he violated visitor or immigration laws hence not “illegal immigrant”.

9

Em42 t1_j5wok2z wrote

If someone has been in a place for 10 years, they're not an immigrant anymore, I don't care what their legal status is. They have assimilated into the culture.

−1

102491593130 t1_j5wzpmb wrote

Chinese guys don't go on shooting rampages, Americans do!

3

[deleted] t1_j5y7hx4 wrote

[deleted]

0

Em42 t1_j5yaqgw wrote

Well I used to work in the courts. A lot of people who basically speak the everyday portion of the language, get interpreters because a lot of times they won't have learned all those specialized legal terms because the only place they're used is in court.

It is not uncommon for someone to have a translator just because they're not a native speakers. If we're going to charge you, especially if you're in a potential death penalty case, we want you to understand and participate in your defense.

Maybe that's not how it works near you, but that is exactly how it works near me, the fact that he has an interpreter has no bearing on whether he speaks English or not, it just means he can't speak the language of the law in English.

−2