The Consumer Reports car buying guide just came out. I highly recommend you pick up a copy- it looks at both new and used cars for reliability, resale, which model years to avoid, etc. we are also in the process and I have found it so helpful. I’m leaning towards a small SUV - former rentals are a great value if you can find one that fits your needs. Usually under a year old and less than 20,000km with a substantial discount ( my last one I saved 30% off list)