Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

AutoModerator t1_irqr24g wrote

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are now allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will continue to be removed and our normal comment rules still apply to other comments.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

Wagamaga OP t1_irqr45y wrote

New research based on data from 18 countries concludes that adults with better mental health are more likely to report having spent time playing in and around coastal and inland waters, such as rivers and lakes (also known collectively as blue spaces) as children.

The finding was replicated in each of the countries studied.

Mounting evidence shows that spending time in and around green spaces such as parks and woodlands in adulthood is associated with stress reduction and better mental health. However, we know far less about the benefits of blue spaces, or the role childhood contact has in these relationships in later life.

Data came from the BlueHealth International Survey (BIS), a cross-sectional survey co-ordinated by the University of Exeter’s European Centre for Environment and Human Health. The current analysis used data from over 15,000 people across 14 European Countries and 4 other non-European countries/regions (Hong Kong, Canada, Australia and California).

Respondents were asked to recall their blue space experiences between the ages of 0-16 years including how local they were, how often they visited them, and how comfortable their parents/guardians were with them playing in these settings, as well as more recent contact with green and blue spaces over the last four weeks, and mental health over the last two weeks.

The research, published in the Journal of Environmental Psychology, found that individuals who recalled more childhood blue space experiences tended to place greater intrinsic value on natural settings in general, and to visit them more often as adults – each of which, in turn, were associated with better mental wellbeing in adulthood.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0272494422001219

43

FrankieMcGigglefits t1_irqtfjq wrote

So where's the study? Am I missing think?

Op only put a link discussing the study.

7

alabasterwilliams t1_irr6kbq wrote

Is water becoming a trigger word?

Water. People like being near water. Almost like it’s a necessary human requirement.

762

Snuggoth t1_irr8nx0 wrote

Dunno, just something weird about a company called BlueHealth spearheading a study that seeks to emphasize blue spaces on the heels of those finding results in green spaces. It's neat, but it does make you wonder about it a little.

337

cantrecoveraccount t1_irrcef6 wrote

Everything was great, bluespaces and greenspaces lived in harmony. Until the red spaces invaded. Now all we have is greyspaces.

137

myversionofyours t1_irreyee wrote

Reminisces in Grandma’s blue living room furniture

1

mascaraforever t1_irrg01t wrote

Admittedly reading this at a red light so can’t read the full article until I get home but I wonder how much economics factor in here. I’m thinking children who are able to take more trips to “blue spaces” are also more likely to be in better off economic situations to begin with.

8

OldApartment9295 t1_irrh25x wrote

I take my kid hiking every weekend when its nice(the weather, not the kid). She complains 3/4 of the way then she’ll be really quiet and finally mention she’s having fun. Its a real drain on my mood but its good for us to go.

546

sciencesnob t1_irrh70i wrote

Not really. In Arkansas they are poor as hell but everyone spends their weekends and summers at the lakes and rivers. We are gifted with bluespaces here and it doesnt cost us to see it.

4

DannyBoy911 t1_irri4j3 wrote

I paint all my walls blue. For the children.

1

sciencesnob t1_irrj04l wrote

People have access to nature unless they live in a cery large city. That isnt a single ancedote. You are thinking ocean or big trip. Im daying a local pond, river, or lake which is literally almost everywhere can count. Poor people have access to look at lakes and rivers. You calling my viewpoint myopic is quite laughable.

12

Dragoness42 t1_irrjxus wrote

Most creeks have an easement where the creek bed itself doesn't really belong to anyone (at least in California, where I have experience). Doesn't mean it has protected access points the same way an ocean beach does, but at least you can walk up and down the creek freely.

5

moosethrow1 t1_irrkg35 wrote

Reddit might as well just start up it's own first party click farm or just accept money directly to market whoever's business.

Same with universities. They're not going to deny free money, there are just too many people involved in a big institution that will use/want that money.

Dunno why I still come to these big subreddits while knowing i'm just going to be marketed at. I think part of it is because I enjoy reading comments, but even comments and users/bots are being bought.

67

Daisend t1_irrkwjt wrote

I was so confused by “blue spaces” I didn’t think it was controversial to say ocean. I was picturing maybe like giant blue rooms.

I did grow up by the beach and also a small forest by my house. I adore going out on hikes. I just assume people who grow up near nature like to be near it as adults as well

42

KillerSpud t1_irrngyf wrote

LD;DR: Go outside sometimes.

21

Outside_Classroom_38 t1_irrpbqz wrote

I don’t understand your comment. I was dirt poor, like the heat turned off regularly. I spent all my time in the river. I collected craw dads so we’d have would have a protein to eat at dinner. I’m pretty sure that would contribute to the happiness of my childhood

17

Rpanich t1_irrwpyh wrote

I mean, homosapiens have existed for 300,000 years, and we only started settling a down, farming, and living in cities 5000 years ago.

Maybe what’s healthiest for humans is the environment we evolved in for 98.5% of our existence: eating a varied diet, getting lots of light cardio, and being around lots of water, plants, and sunlight?

14

jotsea2 t1_irrye7z wrote

Is that why my wife will never move away from Lake Superior after growing up nearby?

3

andrellv t1_irs1xse wrote

I am so sorry to ask this, but what are "blue spaces"? ELI5.

4

left_foot_braker t1_irs25gi wrote

If you’re anything like me, you come to the big subreddits to know how what the internet-engaged part of the collective consciousness is thinking, is aware of and what they are paying attention to. Reddit is a great aggregator for the types of people and opinions you’ll see when you venture out into the real world and gives you tremendous insight into how and what people think. This is especially useful in the current era where people in the real world are largely still obscuring just what parts of the internet they are engaged with.

11

skynetempire t1_irs35jo wrote

I took my sons fishing and they would act up. I then remembered how I was with my dad unable to sit still and want to reel it in right away. The same way my sons are, but my son is older and he told me how much fun he would have fishing. I guess it's worth it at the end

25

BEAMeUPScuT t1_irs47qv wrote

I really wish there were more distance bicycling trails.

It's really nice to go on a long bike ride with family through farmland and forests only to find yourself sheltered at an eccentric little convenience store in the middle of nowhere selling ice-cream sandwiches and lemonade when a storm rolls through.

1

atuan t1_irs5k85 wrote

I wonder if any of these findings apply to unnatural places like public pools.

3

alias4557 t1_irs99tf wrote

My parents used to drag me on outdoor/adventure vacations, and hated it so much at the time. Looking back, I feel so bad, because I appreciate so much the experiences it gave me. Keep up the good fight.

20

Rpanich t1_irsayjq wrote

Oh I think it might just be that: water and the sky.

I don’t think it’s necessarily just children: working in an office with a window is far better than an office without a window.

If that window looks at the sky, the ocean, a forest, a field, a mountain, I imagine those things are all good “green” and/ or “blue” spaces.

If that window faces a brick wall, I bet it would be bad.

But I think the thing might be is that if they painted the brick wall blue or green, it might have the same partial benefit.

1

hazpat t1_irsbdfm wrote

Very first sentence in the article >New research based on data from 18 countries concludes that adults with better mental health are more likely to report having spent time playing in and around coastal and inland waters, such as rivers and lakes (also known collectively as blue spaces) as children. 

3

ashkestar t1_irsfbpz wrote

I mean, it does differentiate between natural water environments and manmade ones. You could put that another way, but given the wide acceptance of “green space,” it does kinda work.

2

noldshit t1_irsfxbg wrote

Makes sense. Gen X was pretty much the last group to be pushed outside to play. All the gen x'ers I know enjoy the outdoors.

1

BlackberryButtons t1_irslvbu wrote

It's super strange, but I know for a fact I bitched incessantly about the constant hiking, road trips and weekend beach visits back in the 90's.

Now I look back and don't remember anything except the texture of it all, and the colors, and the smells of sea air and rainforest wind. And they are some of my best memories!

Part of it I think is that I have ADHD, and so suffering/discomfort has a timeless quality to it. But also other people without ADHD have described the same kind of simplification. Super interesting!

The kids will definitely appreciate it later, as others have said!

74

tvbomb t1_irso9ey wrote

Keep dragging her out. As the kid who grew up with this, who otherwise wouldn’t spend a moment outside and still loves video games to an unhealthy amount, this instilled a love and wonder for the outdoors that still resides in me today. I’m 29 now and just went on a 9 mile hike with Dad for his birthday this weekend. It’s a great way to keep close even though we live a couple hours away from each other now.

38

louderharderfaster t1_irsp1w3 wrote

I am a weird hybrid? I grew up in extreme violence in inner city Detroit but yet our dad had a keen love of nature and 2-3 times a month he would take us out hiking through a specific park + give us a quarter for every plant we could identify. Statistically, I was both fucked and blessed - the upshot is, I have no violent tendencies (brother was not so lucky) and I do have a deep appreciation for nature that feels reciprocal.

It can be hard to get out sometimes but I never regret it.

3

Glum_Ad_4288 t1_irsti4r wrote

Are your parents around for you to let them know how much you value the experience, even though you didn’t show it at the time? I bet they’d really appreciate hearing it now.

8

PaulaLoomisArt t1_irstifz wrote

Are there more poor city kids than poor rural kids? Because as another poor kid who grew up playing in a river, that’s pretty common in rural areas in the United States at least. “Blue spaces” can provide free entertainment, free relief from hot summers, and in some cases, a source of free food as well. My siblings and I spent countless hours around the water and all the neighbor kids did too. These weren’t vacations to a beach somewhere with our parents, just a handful of children playing unsupervised on a muddy river bank.

3

PaulaLoomisArt t1_irsuyyo wrote

I imagine they’re thinking primarily of poor kids in more urban areas, where access to the water is often a luxury. My experience is like yours though, I was a poor rural kid who spent plenty of summers mucking about in the nearest river. I think our experiences are probably similar to that of many other poor children living in the country. The study isn’t viewable for me so I’m not sure how (or if) it accounts for this rural/urban distinction.

6

thecatscatch t1_irsvfmz wrote

It’s a industry/planning term. It covers spaces which has a water (often drainage criteria). Water is too of a broad term as it can also suggest potable water which is about pipe networks. This where it gets fun, lots of new stuff described as blue-green infrastructure which is a growing hybrid field. Like instead of a concrete storm channel, the same system can made via a constructed methods as a naturalised “green” channel so it is essentially a man-made creek. So we would now call this blue-green infrastructure. Then the information in this article would be used as supporting information on why we should build human interaction points on a piece of blue-green infrastructure to make it now a community amenity when previously it would have just have been an infrastructure solution.

3

Rpanich t1_irsy4vw wrote

I know, I’m just trying to explain how colour theory is used; for example when we learned about green spaces, and we decided to paint a bunch of hospitals green and have doctors wear green scrubs, and we found that the benefits carry over.

I’m just trying to venture a guess that perhaps, in the same way the colour “green” might be connected with “green spaces”, the colour “blue” might have the same benefits, as “blue spaces” effects sound very similar to “green space” benefits, and I was only offering a evolutionary hypothesis as to why.

1

zuctronic t1_irt04xd wrote

"New research based on data from 18 countries concludes that adults with better mental health are more likely to report having spent time playing in and around coastal and inland waters, such as rivers and lakes (also known collectively as blue spaces) as children." (first paragraph of the article)

21

lionseatcake t1_irt6x9w wrote

I mean, that water ain't blue anymore pretty much ANy where. So...brown spaces?

0

3eeps t1_irtex9r wrote

Well I grew up beside the ocean, and that's a blue space. I remember my childhood very fondly

1

Aveman19 t1_irtkk9e wrote

Take it from me: my dad would drag the whole family out every summer to the mountains for some hiking. I hated it as a kid, I’d complain non-stop. Fast forward to now - I moved to a city closer to the mountains so I can go out every other week. Nothing warms the soul like a good hike.

3

cesium-sandwich t1_irtl6rh wrote

Yeah. This isn't science. Science would be discussing the socioeconomic/societal structures that are hidden by this overly simplistic metaphor.

0

RojaCatUwu t1_irtlbz0 wrote

"blue spaces": natural sources of water. Ocean/lakes/rivers.

It's in the first paragraph.

2

lucid_life_cycle t1_irtsks1 wrote

I must of had a blue filter googles as a kid, CAUSE I AM A WALKING MELTDOWN

1

whiffling_waterfowl t1_irtxfc1 wrote

>New research based on data from 18 countries concludes that adults with better mental health are more likely to report having spent time playing in and around coastal and inland waters, such as rivers and lakes (also known collectively as blue spaces) as children. 

>The finding was replicated in each of the countries studied.

>Mounting evidence shows that spending time in and around green spaces such as parks and woodlands in adulthood is associated with stress reduction and better mental health. However, we know far less about the benefits of blue spaces, or the role childhood contact has in these relationships in later life.

44

npa100 t1_iru4hat wrote

Am I the only one concerned about that child's grey misshapen head?

2

alias4557 t1_irud1y5 wrote

I had a fat heart to heart with my dad a couple of years ago when we drove halfway across country together. My sisters and I also mention it at family holiday gatherings. We were all little shits back then, I think we’ve been forgiven for most of it.

3

underbuggle t1_irukpjw wrote

I don’t know if this is the same thing- but blue light can reduce the fight or flight response in people who have had TBI/concussions. It reduces the response of the sympathetic nervous system.

1

Stitchandbitch t1_iruo0kq wrote

I’m pretty sure I was this girl 25 years ago when my dad took me camping, hiking and fishing… but as an adult I found my happy place was out in the woods alone. It’s a time to clear my head, recenter myself and remember all the good in life when I’m feeling down or overwhelmed. Ive been so thankful he gave me that gift. He just passed unexpectedly in July and hiking is the only thing that makes me feel close to him and helps get me out of a funk. Great gift he gave me then and you’re giving to your daughter now.

4

Bradley5345 t1_iruoezb wrote

Blue space and green space are two different things in the UK. Here in the US we refer to both as green space. You might also notice that the study none of you have read is from the UK. Maybe these things are correlated.

0

RueRoyal t1_iruub4x wrote

Newspeak. Purposely and methodically limiting your range of thought with confusing and ambiguous new language. Over time you'll think of rivers, lakes and oceans not as what they are but as a commodity called blue space. You'll wonder if you're getting enough blue space, or if you deserve some blue space time. Enjoy.

6

PPP1737 t1_iruxl3y wrote

What is this beehive toddler face mask in the pic? Is that like some attempt at anonymously using a child model or…

1

alberthere t1_irv2dlx wrote

Sweet home Alabama. Where the skies are so blue.

1

DeTrotseTuinkabouter t1_irv6h2g wrote

Wouldn't call the beach a green space. Some might have it with dunes behind it, but absolutely not all.

And I live in Amsterdam with lots of water. The river Amstel flows through the city and we have a bunch of canals. But not every place next to those is a green space. While I do think we all really enjoy the water and you'll have kids swimming in it in the summer (and us adults as well).

3

Splenda t1_irwp77t wrote

Go for the gross. Secretly drop some milk duds on the trail, then taste them to "identify the deer species". Or lick a worm or a slug, then dare her to do the same. Kids love it.

Then, at night, be sure to watch meteors, ask her to count the stars in The Pleiades, and look at the Andromeda galaxy with binoculars.

1