Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

AllyEmmie t1_j25uqd4 wrote

Reply to comment by inelasticplastick in What AI thinks Vermont looks like by PorkFriedBryce

You can’t “make art yourself” through AI. The AI stole images off of the internet that belonged to an actual artist, and then made a new image with it. Any prompt created through AI isn’t your art. It’s stolen material.

−1

nixxon t1_j27ed0a wrote

Theoretically that'll get sorted out when people start trying to sell these (good luck with that, btw). Like sampling in music. You can do it if you're creating something new, but you have to pay the creator.

2

inelasticplastick t1_j26e82b wrote

can one make art themself with a pencil?

1

AllyEmmie t1_j27xp3l wrote

I don't understand the relevance of your rhetorical question.

1

inelasticplastick t1_j281t96 wrote

i wasn’t asking my question rhetorically

i view paper and pencil as analagous as art-making tools

my understanding of the law regarding art reproduction seems to be different than u. i guess ais alter images prior to delivery. if that’s the case, assuming the amount of alteration is sufficient, i don’t see any infringement

1

AllyEmmie t1_j2aodpa wrote

If a human being makes art, and then posts it on the internet, with their brand or signature attached, and then a human-made AI STEALS THAT ART, so YOU can make art WITH THE AI, then that should be illegal

I don't know why you're saying what you're saying. AI is BAD.

1

inelasticplastick t1_j2apr4k wrote

it’s not illegal tho

all creative outputs are iterations and there is law about how much a work needs to change in order to be “different enough”

0

AllyEmmie t1_j2bb6tl wrote

Copyright is a law. And if an artist makes something by their own hand, YOU ARE NOT ENTITLED TO TAKE IT, AND CLAIM IT AS YOURS.

YOU can't do that. And an AI shouldn't be allowed to do that either.

AI takes ORIGINAL art pieces, mashes them together, and gives you the result of the prompt you typed in. It's highly grey, lawfully.

1