Blecher_onthe_Hudson

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_iu6bkbf wrote

I'm trying to see how we spend more than anyone else in the nation on our school system. Sorting helps understand the context. Say we are near the top of our group in teacher salaries, but what if the group only varies by a few percent, then that's not conclusive of much, right? But without sorting by spending, that's hard to see.

I downloaded the files since they no longer allow you to view the data online as in the past.

1

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_iu4y7vw wrote

Just pointing out the lowest hanging fruit, even with bloated admin staff there's still a lot more teachers, that's where most of the money goes.

I have a mea culpa, I already admitted I'm not an Excel wiz, I was misreading the spreadsheet about which was the most recent data and quoted from 2019-20. But it raises more questions.

From file CSG3.xlsx at https://www.nj.gov/education/guide/2022/ind.shtml, The teachers salaries went from 85/92 in 2019-20, to 55/92 in 2021-22! That's quite a shift in a scenario with 92 datapoints. It says the actual cost per student dropped from $10,807 to $10,120. Seems way more likely to me they're cooking the books not cutting payroll. Are you actually a CPA? Do you know how to fix these files so they can be re-sorted?

2

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_iu2jmqi wrote

>The very over-simplified version is that the schools are kinda meh fucking awful but also super expensive to run (as a result of the state cutting back it’s funding decades of generous contracts because we weren't the ones paying). “Education Matters” candidates are backed by the teachers union and would attempt to prioritize quality of education staff pay and benefits. They are also the current group with control over the board.

Fixed this for you. As I posted elsewhere today, the fact that maintenance staff make more than 98% of their NJ peers, teacher 92%, and the district ranks 11th percentile (bottom) in extracurricular spending tells you all you need to know about Education Matters priorities.

The fact that Change For Children is backed by developers doesn't mean that no one should stand up to the idea that unions should control our schools.Someone has to! One could even argue they're literally more invested in JC's future than school staff who live in the suburbs.

Data source: https://www.nj.gov/education/guide/2022/ind.shtml

18

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_iu24oad wrote

Very true. I will point out that both JC and Hoboken have done a crappy job of maintaining both the stripes and the plastic poles. One spot in particular, Harrison between Observer and NY Ave, the stripe is gone and it creates a hazard for drivers who know the bike lane is there! Several times when I've kept left out of the bike lane I've had asshole drivers pull up to the right of me in the bike lane even though the block ends in a single lane right turn only.

Also the daylighting combined with the bike lanes creates an untenable situation for delivery drivers. Some blocks there's now simply no place to pull over except double parking in the bike lane, and they have to get their job done. This is where engineering rather than enforcement has created a shitshow.

1

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_iu11dmt wrote

The spending data the state makes available is deliberately impenetrable. They used to provide a spreadsheet per district with all the categories of spending statistics, but I guess that was too useful, now each category is a spreadsheet for every district statewide.https://www.nj.gov/education/guide/2022/ind.shtml

They provide defective spreadsheets where the sort functions don't work! I'm not an excel wizard, but with patience you can mine out tidbits. How about these comparisons of cost to other large districts in NJ.

Salaries and Benefits for Operations and Maintenance of Plant: 90|92. That is, we pay more per student than 89 out of 91 other NJ districts.

Teachers: 85|92 They're among the best paid in NJ, which means the best paid in the nation.

Extracurriculars: 10|92. We spend less than 81 out of 91 peer districts. No wonder our kids hate school! We're taking their school enrichment experience and giving it to overpaid teachers and maintenance workers.

13

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_iu0j9jd wrote

I'm not any happier about the taxes than anyone else, but I just want to inject some reality in to the "taxed out of our home!" hyperbole. If you owned for the last 5 years you saw a 30-50% increase in your value, you're sitting on a pile of equity, you're not poor. Lets say the rate goes up to 2%, do you really think that over the next 10 years your appreciate will average less than 2% annually?

So many people want the financial benefits of owning property but aren't willing to pay the overhead. If you are cash poor, there's a number of ways the banks can help you pay your taxes.

As I said during the reval, the city would be smart to set up a "tax deferral lien" bond system in lieu of the much maligned reverse mortgage. The way it would work is if you can't pay your taxes, the city puts a lien on your property to be resolved upon eventually transfer (similar to reverse mortgage), and sells the bundled liens as bonds. You essentially get a loan at interest, the city gets it's money, the bondholders make profit. Everybody wins, including the property owner who still gets their appreciation while not paying taxes.

2

Blecher_onthe_Hudson t1_itydwnz wrote

OMG, there is a dumpster fire over on Nextdoor that reminds me of the heyday of JCList. People who have no idea what the reval was all about and have no idea what's going on with the schools.

There are downtowners who made a million dollars in the last 10 years on their row house complaining they can't pay a 2% property tax! The disinterest in what goes on in this city until it reaches into their purse is just fucking amazing.

16

Blecher_onthe_Hudson OP t1_itxyvnt wrote

Mmmm, bulgogi. Last time I had it was in the food court of a bigass mall in Seattle when went to the mall for a well rated Chinese restaurant that told us a 2 hr wait. We were just looking for food before crashing in a motel for super early flight!

There used to be a big steam table type deli at 14th & 6th that had Bulgogi platters to go in a hot case for cheap. Coming back from a seeing a client in Queens I'd get off the F, get my Bulgogi fix, then hop on the PATH.

1

Blecher_onthe_Hudson OP t1_itxcjf2 wrote

>I am told is that, like other pickled items, it never really goes bad.

I dunno about that, sour pickles especially get soft and nasty. I like to buy them 1/2 sour and let them sit on the counter till the bright green just leaves, then they're perfect! But even refrigerated they don't stay that way very long. You also have to get the ones with no preservatives to do that.

2