Castlegardener
Castlegardener t1_ivqy5cr wrote
Reply to comment by SnowMantra in [SP] "I wish for supernatural charisma." "Done! You have two wishes left." "Only two?" by SpookieSkelly
It's even worse than that. Without medical intervention John will die of dehydration after a few days because the action of drinking water now doesn't lead to the consequence of rehydration, the action of moving his limbs won't lead to the consequence of moving forward in space and so on. John is royally fucked.
Castlegardener t1_ivqyks4 wrote
Reply to comment by Junk4Brains in [SP] "I wish for supernatural charisma." "Done! You have two wishes left." "Only two?" by SpookieSkelly
By that point in time John would already be dead. Simply because drinking, moving etc are actions. Actions which don't lead to the desired outcomes anymore because there are no consequences to them.