D_is_for_Doomsayer

D_is_for_Doomsayer t1_iy85bv4 wrote

Everything you say is true, but I think you're looking too close at what's intentionally a bigger picture story. The movie is operating as a hamfisted allegory. Nada is a cypher. In general, the characters are less characters than they are representations of types of people.

So yes, Nada is not an especially good or smart person. He doesn't have to be though because the movie isn't serving us up a story about characters so much as using them like props to reveal a broader social commentary.

21

D_is_for_Doomsayer t1_ixs0px2 wrote

I agree with this interpretation. No, he was not mentally ill by the standards of the day, just hard headed, individualistic, and hypermasculine. His problems are primarily social. Yet, when we look at folks like this in the justice system now, we see high rates of trauma, anxiety and mood disorders, brain injury, and general poor family and social supports.

Let's also say that mental health is not a binary.

7

D_is_for_Doomsayer t1_iwndhna wrote

The Decemberists almost fit the bill for The Crane Wife and The Hazards of Love, but both have more characters and intermission songs of sorts.

Devin Townsend Presents Ziltoid the Omniscient (a few songs are supplementary to Ziltoid's story)

Pink Floyd The Wall

Deltron 3030 S/T

3