Even_Stay3387
Even_Stay3387 OP t1_iyw3bfm wrote
Reply to comment by Artichoke-Lower in [D] Score 4.5 GNN paper from Muhan Zhang at Peking University was amazingly accepted by NeurIPS 2022 by Even_Stay3387
This is not real. You could check the reviewer and the author have discussed many rounds. The reviewers said the concerns are not addressed. I am very confused why ac said the reviewers are outdated!!
Even_Stay3387 OP t1_iyvyx5w wrote
Reply to comment by dojoteef in [D] NeurIPS 2022 Outstanding Paper modified results significantly in the camera ready by Even_Stay3387
are you sure this is allowed? data leakage... really funny. I can also post a very very good results to cheat the review and then say I am sorry there is data leakage here.
Even_Stay3387 OP t1_iyw3rb4 wrote
Reply to comment by UnusualClimberBear in [D] Score 4.5 GNN paper from Muhan Zhang at Peking University was amazingly accepted by NeurIPS 2022 by Even_Stay3387
You could check the rebuttal process. Reviewers and authors discussed many rounds. Reviewers said concerns are not addressed. It is really ridiculous to say reviewers are outdated.