HRJafael

HRJafael OP t1_j1zxptp wrote

I watched "Drew" last night. It deviates greatly from the books and uses the character names. Still, it was an interesting watch and it did give off the vibe of "The Nancy Drew Files" which was a books series in the 1980s that was darker and grittier than the classic books. Not sure about the NYC detective angle but I guess they didn't want to do another small town mystery series yet again (not that the NYC choice was any better).

This was passed over by CBS who decided to pick up "Doubt" instead, which was another pilot written by the same people who wrote "Drew". That ended up being cancelled so it's up in the air whether or not "Drew" would have done better or not.

1

HRJafael t1_j1qg54e wrote

The thing that upsets me about this is how well-done the adaptation is. The screenwriter Sarah Phelps went on to adapt other Christie novels, including "The Pale Horse" (one of my favorites from Christie) and completely butchered it. It still boggles my mind that she was able to get the tone of the book perfect for "And Then There Were None" but then drop the ball on the other equally creepy novel. She had great potential but then went off the rails with other Christie adaptations.

9