LurkersWillLurk

LurkersWillLurk t1_ixiry6g wrote

No, what I’m saying is that you are fundamentally not happy with a sentence that’s not life plus cancer for any kind of violent crime. You think that any time a criminal reoffends that it’s a policy failure, yet you also probably don’t think that it’s a policy failure to keep someone incarcerated longer than necessary to prevent them from reoffending. Where are the righteously indignant Fox29 stories about elderly inmates taking up space in Laurel Highlands?

Bottom line is, this case is not a policy failure by the DAO. The severity of punishment is insignificant compared to the certainty of punishment. You’re missing the forest for the trees if all you consider is that this particular person wouldn’t have participated in this particular robbery if he had been given a marginally longer sentence.

−10

LurkersWillLurk t1_ixiogzx wrote

Incapacitation is great and all but he would have been let go in two or three years. Do you have a crystal ball to show that the same result wouldn’t have happened later down the line? I’m sure you would’ve complained had he been arrested later on that the sentence of three years for aggravated assault was a joke.

Secondly, there are plenty of other counties that would’ve given that low of a sentence, for a wide variety of reasons. Reasons like limited prosecutorial resources, unwillingness of witnesses to testify, or just generally weak evidence from the police.

The guidelines are merely just guidelines - if he took it to trial and lost, he would’ve gotten a longer time in prison, but he gave up his right to a trial in exchange for a reduced sentence. And he still managed to get a probation violation warrant that Philly Police and the Sheriff’s Office ignored until after he was picked up for robbery.

−20

LurkersWillLurk t1_iu4ob3a wrote

Definitely the best option. You can also call Transit Police at 215-580-8111 or text them at 215-234-1911. I would highly recommend saving both of these to your contacts.

Every subway car has a number somewhere within it. Try to find that number and make sure you tell it to Transit Police whenever you contact them.

126