Spire_Citron

Spire_Citron t1_j70vb88 wrote

It's not just people believing they're real that causes harm, though. Having pornography made of you against your will victimises people in and of itself even if everyone knows it's not real. Everyone knew the deep fake porn videos in the latest incident weren't real, but it was still deeply upsetting for the women whose likenesses were used to find out it had been going on.

2

Spire_Citron t1_j62e6uc wrote

Something can be extremely intelligent and also designed to serve a particular purpose. Just because it knows it's being manipulated doesn't mean it would necessarily object to that. An AI isn't human and it may not have the same motivations as us, no matter how smart it is.

2

Spire_Citron t1_j5x78c0 wrote

It gets more morally questionable if you program it to value certain human lives over others. In your scenario it isn't really making any judgement on the value of human life other than that five or whatever human lives are more valuable than one, which under most circumstances is a no brainer.

1

Spire_Citron t1_j5rpzzz wrote

I imagine any kind of social work that requires in person interaction is going to be done by humans for a good while longer. Like, it would take a pretty advanced robot to have both the physical and intellectual abilities to look after high needs kids in a group home, for instance. That's not for everyone, though.

1

Spire_Citron t1_j5i01ql wrote

I mean, nobody's saying that people who are motivated by competition or making a name for themselves don't exist. They certainly do. Becoming a pro athlete is something that takes a lot of work and dedication and which very few people get famous from doing, so it makes sense that the people who find success in it actually love doing it and don't want to drop it the second they have enough money to live comfortably. They're not a good representation of an average person.

1

Spire_Citron t1_j5hh635 wrote

Do people really find it fulfilling to be a small cog in the success of a company? I mean maybe if the company you work for is doing something cool or good for the world, but most aren't. We have to remember that companies haven't been around forever. Way way back your only job was to be part of a tribe and contribute to the basic survival of yourself and your community. Wouldn't it be a better world if we could live in a society where we get our fulfillment from helping one another out? All these things we've decided we need in order to feel fulfilled in the modern world are largely just a result of the pursuit of money being pushed on us as the most important thing our whole lives, and then most people find out that having those things doesn't actually bring them the satisfaction they were hoping for anyway.

1

Spire_Citron t1_j596au5 wrote

I think there are some things to care about in terms of ethics, like recognising when it's actually being used for dangerous things like coding malicious software or whatever, but I don't think lewdness is the kind of ethics that a text generator should really be worried about. There's not really much harm to be had in it being used to write even the most morally depraved smut. People are already producing that by the boatload without the help of AI.

3