We looked into this one, which definitely matched what I think we were looking for, but ultimately I think a place that was a little less... Cramped? Definitely captures that homestyle feeling, but the reviews mentioned that I can get pretty loud and the place is small. Maybe another time.

Lots of great suggestions, but we did end up choosing Serafino's! Exactly what we were looking for, felt like a family restaurant! Very good food, very cozy feeling, and the people were great!