goatAlmighty
goatAlmighty t1_j9qls4r wrote
Funny, just a day or two ago I created a post not too dissimilar, specifically regarding male singers. :-D But specifically regarding your observation, I think too many musicians have forgotten how to write happy music nowadays.
goatAlmighty t1_j8y8wmk wrote
Reply to comment by Test19s in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
Unfortunately, we're living in an age where this is proven day in, day out. Every ideology tends to turn into extremism when given too much power.
goatAlmighty t1_j8swqoh wrote
Reply to comment by Remarkable-Hall-9478 in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
Stop implying something I've never said. Shout as long as you want, but the original link (and Gataca, imho), isn't about eliminating illnesses as such, but about either favoring certain embryos and/or forcing people to take careers that fit their genetic outfit, no matter if they want to or not. So forget things like freedom of any kind.
Selecting embryos due to their (perceived) chances for future college is a f*cked up idea. It's euthanasia for nothing else but, basically, intelligence. And it will, once again, favor those who can afford it and leave all others in the dust.
Eliminating illnesses on a larger scale is a completely different matter, but even that purpose is debatable. There are parents who are willing to give their unborn child a chance even if they know that it has some kind of genetic defect. And even if such measures would be reliable in the future, they'll most probably wouldn't be for the masses but for the few who can afford them.
The end result would be some very healthy, very intelligent rich people and an endless stream of poor people who, due to their "faulty" genetic composition, would be seen as mere underlings, only there to serve those that are "worthy" of good education and jobs.
goatAlmighty t1_j8qsg1r wrote
Reply to comment by sexy_starfish in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
Thank you, I will definitely give that a listen. I'm from Germany, so I'm not that familiar with US-history. But given the stance of several of their secret services and what kind of "experiments" they did with their own citizens, I'm not surprised that they went into eugenics as well.
goatAlmighty t1_j8qrdw6 wrote
Reply to comment by krumpdawg in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
I would agree. I can see why some people would defend it, but it's not a world I'd want to live in. I mean, there's a reason that it's officially called a "dystopian" movie. It's kind of like with "Equilibrium" or "Elysium". Your life might be fine, as long as you fit the parameters to be on the winners' side, but if not, you're in a living hell.
goatAlmighty t1_j8qqdi6 wrote
Reply to comment by Josvan135 in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
It is certainly debatable what is acceptable and what is not. But, for me at least, the thought of living in a world without any kind of personal freedom, where more or less society decides for you what you ought to be doing, is a pretty horrible scenario.
goatAlmighty t1_j8qq5jr wrote
Reply to comment by krumpdawg in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
This is not a condemnation, but I think, in actuality, he would probably be seen as a pretty good citizen, for the fact that he agrees with the whole eugenics- and pre-selection thing that is expressed in the movie. It's a stand one can take, for sure, and I see their reasons, but I disagree wholeheartedly with it.
goatAlmighty t1_j8qpwtx wrote
Reply to comment by Josvan135 in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
In movies like this, those that are "perfect" in the eyes of society often don't have such a terrible life. But all the others suffer. In the case of Gattaca particularly the most abhorrent thing to me is the eugenics (something that is banned for a good reason, not only because the Nazis implemented something along these lines, according to their state of technology back then). In my opinion, the whole scenario leads to a kind of slavery where one isn't granted any personal freedom, not better than what happens in an ant-state, devoid of any humanity.
goatAlmighty t1_j8of051 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
People are already cloning their "beloved" pets to have them around again after they die... So yeah, I'm not surprised.
goatAlmighty t1_j8oesxw wrote
Reply to Americans are ready to test embryos for future college chances, survey shows by ChickenTeriyakiBoy1
Welcome to the world of Gattaca. Or Brave New World...
goatAlmighty t1_j6o06j6 wrote
Reply to What’s the song? by thiccims
"Heaven in my hands" by Level 42?
goatAlmighty t1_j9qnca4 wrote
Reply to comment by xmarcotics in Why don’t we have the 2010s style pop music anymore? by xmarcotics
:-D