manwnomelanin
manwnomelanin t1_jacshcw wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
Clearly, the implications were there. Again, whether you meant to or not.
Hence the downvotes.
I don’t think anyone here would disagree that you should spend all dollars thoughtfully. Clearly that isn’t what you communicated
manwnomelanin t1_jackyi3 wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
Whether you meant to or not, you did
Ultimately I agree if that’s the point you’re trying to make. Although I still think it’s poor advice in this context
Edit: I guess I don’t agree given my second sentence.
It may be better on paper, but that fails to consider emotional components which are important. You say it never hurts, but it is clearly hurting OP
We disagree on a philosophical level. I don’t think its healthy or worthwhile to avoid consumption like the plague. You should enjoy life a little.
To each their own
manwnomelanin t1_jaceyx2 wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
You can spend thoughtfully and still enjoy yourself.
You should be looser with the money leftover after allocating a portion to specific savings goals. You have to live a little
Especially in the context of OP’s situation who is clearly depriving themselves of basic life experiences.
Your advice alludes to spending money only on basic necessities and nothing else, even if that isn’t what you meant
manwnomelanin t1_jace6bu wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
> a specific purpose
This leads to the paradoxical line of thinking i mentioned before
> an unanticipated need
Isn’t that what an emergency fund is for?
You imply hoarding. You can spend thoughtfully while still enjoying the money that isn’t delegated to a specific savings bucket.
manwnomelanin t1_jabii87 wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
This is just an endless paradox
Thinking this way, you will never spend money in anticipation of some hypothetical better opportunity down the line
manwnomelanin t1_jabhsuw wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
Why would you hoard money with no purpose?
Its a tool, not a collectable
manwnomelanin t1_j6pedy8 wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
You should do that then
manwnomelanin t1_j6pdbi4 wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Okay, then i still do not understand what you’re saying
I don’t think you’re using the term rollover correctly
I would contact a fidelity rep for assistance so they can talk you through all the terms and implications
manwnomelanin t1_j6p9j62 wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
So you rolled over your old 401k to a new 401k plan at your new job?
manwnomelanin t1_j6p82p8 wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Im going to be honest with you, what you’re saying doesn’t make any sense
What do you think rolling over has to do with your job closing?
Thats where you’re losing me
manwnomelanin t1_j6p7iqe wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Are you planning to roll it over and then withdraw when your job closes?
manwnomelanin t1_j6p6dwp wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Are you trying to withdraw or rollover?
manwnomelanin t1_j6p5tsy wrote
Its worth asking your landlord if you’re both on the lease. He may be able to light a fire under him
But at the end of the day he is not obligated to give you any leway. You’re responsible for covering the full amount
manwnomelanin t1_j6p4u9h wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Your new job has nothing to do with your old 401k
manwnomelanin t1_j6p0twv wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Yes, you will lose a proportionally significant amount in taxes and penalties
manwnomelanin t1_j6ozsxh wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
I’m not sure what you’re asking
Sounds like 401k balance is too low to be kept where it is now that your employment has been terminated.
If you do not roll those funds over into an IRA or 401k with your new employer by 5/8/2023, you will be issued a check for the balance and your account will be closed.
From there, you could deposit it into your bank and accept the taxes and penalties if that is what you wish
If you want the money sooner, you’ll have to fill out a distribution form with your brokerage and have the money withdrawn/direct deposited to your bank.
Again, a rep from the brokerage can answer all of these questions
manwnomelanin t1_j6otrqe wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
It depends on if your employer was contributing and, if so, whether or not that money was vested before you left
manwnomelanin t1_j6otki5 wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
If they won’t answer, then I’d reach out to the help desk at brokerage where your 401k is
manwnomelanin t1_j6ot9g2 wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Is your 401k through your new job or old job?
manwnomelanin t1_j6oszdp wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Yes you do
Ask HR
manwnomelanin t1_j6osbt3 wrote
Reply to What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
OP, you should talk to your plan administrator.
Based on your questions and comments, I don’t think you should navigate this on your own. Talking to a real person close to the situation would be worthwhile
manwnomelanin t1_j6os7ru wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
Thats why its asking for an IRA account number. You told them you were rolling it into an IRA
manwnomelanin t1_j6os4vr wrote
Reply to comment by OverCastle28 in What is my IRA account number? by OverCastle28
First option
Its asking for an IRA account number because you selected the second option
manwnomelanin t1_j6oerta wrote
Reply to comment by UltimatePlayer3301 in Is it feasible to buy a house with 3 friends for my 4 years in college (or maybe longer)? by UltimatePlayer3301
Thats what they’d effectively be doing if theyre all co signing lol
manwnomelanin t1_jacteix wrote
Reply to comment by bpt3 in When does saving become unhealthy? by Narrow-Imagination96
> continue this conversation with yourself
You are right - this is much like talking to a wall